Free SEO Audit Checklist for a New Website: 15 Checks

Fifteen checks that find most SEO problems on a new site, each with the rule to meet and a free way to test it: crawling, indexing, on-page, speed, AI search.

Fifteen checks find most of the SEO problems on a new website, and none of them needs a paid tool. Each check below has the rule to meet and a free way to test it. Work in order: the first six decide whether search engines can read the site at all, and the rest is polish that only matters once they can.

Crawling and indexing

1. One address for each page. The bare domain, http and a trailing slash should all redirect (301) to one address. Follow each variant with the redirect checker.

2. A robots.txt that answers 200 and blocks nothing public. A server error on this file makes Google treat the whole site as blocked for a time. Read robots.txt for the rules, or build the file with the robots.txt generator.

3. No stray noindex. noindex can sit in a meta tag or in an X-Robots-Tag header, and a staging setting often survives the launch. The meta tag checker shows the tag and the HTTP header checker shows the header.

4. A canonical on every page that names the page itself. The canonical tag must be an absolute address that answers 200.

5. A sitemap of canonical pages only. An XML sitemap holds up to 50,000 URLs or 50 MB in one file. List only pages that answer 200 and may be indexed, and submit it in Google Search Console and Bing Webmaster Tools.

6. A real 404 for an address that does not exist. Type a random path. A "not found" page that answers 200 is a soft 404, and Google asks for a 404 status instead.

On the page

7. One title for each page, subject first. Google cuts the title link to the width of the result, about 50 to 60 characters. See title tag, and test yours in the SERP preview.

8. A meta description of about 150 to 160 characters. It is not a ranking factor, but it is often the text under your title. See meta description. We ran this check on SEOAnything on 20 November 2026 and found 12 of our own descriptions over 160 characters; all are trimmed now.

9. One h1, and headings in order. The h1 says what the page is, and h2 and h3 divide it without skipping a level.

10. Structured data that parses and matches the page. Start with Organization on the home page and Article or BlogPosting on posts. See structured data. The structured data checker lists the types on a page, blocks that fail to parse and missing core properties.

11. The text is in the HTML. View the page source. If the words are not there, a crawler that does not run JavaScript sees an empty page, and Google has to queue the page for rendering.

Speed

12. Core Web Vitals in the "good" range. The thresholds are 2.5 seconds for Largest Contentful Paint, 200 milliseconds for Interaction to Next Paint and 0.1 for Cumulative Layout Shift, each met by 75% of real visits. See Core Web Vitals, and test a page in Google's PageSpeed Insights.

The server's own response time is part of loading. On SEOAnything the home page took 0.4 to 0.7 seconds to first byte until 20 November 2026, because the server fetched the built page from another network on every request. Keeping the page in memory brought it to about 0.07 seconds.

13. Every page is linked from another page. Use real <a href> links with anchor text that names the target. A page that only the sitemap mentions is an orphan. Group related pages and link each one back to its hub: that is how topical authority is built.

14. AI search crawlers are allowed in. ChatGPT search, Claude and Perplexity read the web with their own crawlers, and a block in robots.txt or at the firewall removes a site from their answers. robots.txt for AI crawlers lists them.

15. The brand is a clear entity. Use one spelling of the name, an About page, and Organization data with sameAs links to your official profiles. See entity SEO.

What should you fix first?

PriorityChecksWhy
First1 to 6A page that cannot be crawled or indexed gains nothing from the rest
Second11, 13, 14Content that crawlers cannot read or reach is invisible
Third7 to 10, 15These shape how a result looks and what it is understood to be
Fourth12Speed matters most once the pages are found

What does this checklist not cover?

It leaves out backlinks and keyword search volumes, because both need data that free tools do not hold. SEOAnything has neither. The comparison pages say when a paid suite such as Semrush or Ahrefs is the better pick.

It also cannot tell you whether a page deserves to rank. That is a question of content: does the page answer what the searcher asked, in its first sentences, with something of its own? Search intent and BLUF are the two ideas to read next.

How do you run it quickly?

For one page, paste its address into the check on the home page: it is free and needs no account. For a whole site, Search Visibility crawls up to 500 pages and returns the fixes in order, with the evidence for each. If a page is still missing from Google after the fixes, go through why a page is not indexed.

Sources: Google's SEO starter guide, how Google interprets robots.txt, the Page indexing report and web.dev on Web Vitals.

FAQ

Do I need paid tools for an SEO audit?

Not for these 15 checks: each can be tested with a free tool or by viewing the page source. Backlink data and keyword search volumes do need a paid suite.

What should I fix first after an SEO audit?

Anything that stops crawling or indexing: redirects to one address, robots.txt, noindex, canonical tags, the sitemap and real 404 responses. Titles, descriptions and speed matter only once pages can be read and indexed.

What are the Core Web Vitals thresholds?

2.5 seconds or less for Largest Contentful Paint, 200 milliseconds or less for Interaction to Next Paint and 0.1 or less for Cumulative Layout Shift, each met by 75% of real visits.

Share this post

Comments 0

    Publish yours next.

    Write it yourself, or turn a rising search into a scored draft. Your readers need no account.

    Write a post

    Research your own topic: see what each market searches today, find the words people type with keyword research, check a page with the free SEO tools, or look up a term in the SEO glossary.

    More from the blog